• Register
• Sell
  • Learn More
  • Register to Sell
• Auctions
  • Baseball(476)
  • Basketball(44)
  • Football(76)
  • Hockey(90)
  • Other Cards(82)
• Help
  • User's Guide
  • Help/Contact Sportlots

Learn more about the Sportlots Baseball Card Values Guide.

Mel Stottlemyre Baseball Trading Card Values

Card Description	NM	EX/NM	EX	VG	GOOD

1965 O-Pee-Chee OPC #133 Mel Stottlemyre				$2.48	$1.30
1965 Topps #550 Mel Stottlemyre	$3.52	$15.52	$15.28	$12.52	$8.52
1966 Topps #350 Mel Stottlemyre	$15.52	$11.03	$5.53	$9.03	$2.52
1966 Topps Rub-Offs Inserts #88 Mel Stottlemyre	$4.53	$2.53	$5.53
1967 Topps #225 Mel Stottlemyre	$5.51	$2.69	$1.32	$1.93	$0.75
1968 O-Pee-Chee OPC #120 Mel Stottlemyre				$1.78
1968 Topps #120 Mel Stottlemyre	$3.53	$5.38	$2.36	$2.02	$1.35
1969 O-Pee-Chee OPC Deckle #21 Mel Stottlemyre			$2.53		$0.90
1969 Globe Imports Playing Cards #5S Mel Stottlemyre	$0.41				$0.23
1969 Milton Bradley #265 Mel Stottlemyre			$3.53
1969 MLB PhotoStamps #NNO Mel Stottlemyre	$1.25
1969 Nabisco Team Flakes #24 Mel Stottlemyre				$1.78	$1.02
1969 Topps #470 Mel Stottlemyre	$3.03	$2.36	$1.05	$0.95	$1.05
1969 Topps #470 Mel Stottlemyre				$10.86
1969 Topps Decals Inserts #42 Mel Stottlemyre		$1.89
1969 Topps Deckle Inserts #13 Mel Stottlemyre	$1.00	$1.34	$0.73	$1.35	$0.41
1970 Kelloggs #5 Mel Stottlemyre	$4.42		$2.92	$2.44
1970 O-Pee-Chee OPC #100 Mel Stottlemyre		$1.37	$0.81	$1.15
1970 Milton Bradley #27 Mel Stottlemyre	$3.53			$1.50
1970 Topps #100 Mel Stottlemyre	$1.78	$0.63	$0.38	$0.41	$0.34
1970 Topps Scratchoffs #22 Mel Stottlemyre	$5.03	$1.95	$6.53	$0.34	$0.72
1970 Topps Super #27 Mel Stottlemyre	$20.80		$2.61		$5.58
1971 Kelloggs #40 Mel Stottlemyre	$10.40	$8.48	$5.53	$3.52	$1.17
1971 O-Pee-Chee OPC #615 Mel Stottlemyre	$25.50
1971 Dell Todays Team Stamps #524 Mel Stottlemyre	$0.55
1971 New York Yankees Clinic Day Postcards #12 Mel Stottlemyre	$3.02
1971 Topps #615 Mel Stottlemyre	$30.52	$7.27	$10.48	$1.68	$1.30
1971 Topps Coins Inserts #94 Mel Stottlemyre	$4.28	$2.53	$1.18	$1.31	$0.94
1971 Topps Scratch-Offs #NNO Mel Stottlemyre				$1.35
1971 Topps Super #10 Mel Stottlemyre				$2.52
1972 Kelloggs #50 Mel Stottlemyre	$4.48	$2.53			$1.13
1972 O-Pee-Chee OPC #492 Mel Stottlemyre					$1.78
1972 Topps #325 Mel Stottlemyre	$0.32	$0.90	$0.38	$0.65	$0.99
1972 Topps #492 Mel Stottlemyre	$2.33	$1.78	$1.28	$1.78	$0.34
1973 O-Pee-Chee OPC #520 Mel Stottlemyre	$3.38	$1.71	$0.91	$1.31	$0.33
1973 Topps #520 Mel Stottlemyre	$2.36	$2.53	$0.39	$0.55	$0.55
1974 O-Pee-Chee OPC #44 Mel Stottlemyre			$0.64	$0.47
1974 Topps #44 Mel Stottlemyre	$1.35	$2.52	$0.68	$0.34	$0.34
1975 O-Pee-Chee OPC #183 Mel Stottlemyre	$0.71		$1.35	$0.71	$0.58
1975 Topps #183 Mel Stottlemyre	$1.28	$1.00	$0.41	$0.41	$0.34
1975 Topps Minis #183 Mel Stottlemyre	$2.03	$1.25	$1.05	$0.93
1983 TCMA 50 Years of Yankee All-Stars #46 Mel Stottlemyre	$0.75
1983 Team Issue New York Yankees A-S Fifty Years #46 Mel Stottlemyre	$0.34
1988 Pacific Legends I/II #22 Mel Stottlemyre	$0.34	$0.34
1988 Team Issue New York Mets Kahns #NNO Mel Stottlemyre	$0.34
1989 Bowman #261 Mel Stottlemyre	$0.34
1989 Bowman Tiffany #261 Mel Stottlemyre	$0.60
1989 Team Issue New York Mets Kahns #26 Mel Stottlemyre	$0.34
1990 CMC #182 Mel Stottlemyre	$0.34	$0.24
1990 Leaf #310 Mel Stottlemyre	$0.26
1991 Donruss #257 Mel Stottlemyre	$0.34
1991 Score #361 Mel Stottlemyre	$0.34
1991 Topps #58 Mel Stottlemyre	$0.34
1992 Team Issue New York Yankees WIZ All Stars #81 Mel Stottlemyre	$0.41
2000 Fleer Greats of the Game #51 Mel Stottlemyre	$0.34	$0.34
2000 Upper Deck Yankees Legends #47 Mel Stottlemyre	$0.34
2003 Upper Deck Sweet Spot Classics #135 Mel Stottlemyre	$0.90
2003 Upper Deck Yankees Signature #58 Mel Stottlemyre	$0.75
2003 Upper Deck Yankees Signature Pride of New York Autos #MS Mel Stottlemyre	$8.00
2004 Upper Deck Yankees Classics #46 Mel Stottlemyre	$0.34
2008 Team Issue New York Yankees Hero Decks #12D Mel Stottlemyre	$1.35
2010 TRISTAR Obak #51 Mel Stottlemyre	$0.34
2014 Topps Archives 1969 Deckle Minis #MS Mel Stottlemyre	$1.20
2014 Topps Heritage 1965 50th Anniversary Buybacks #550 Mel Stottlemyre					$8.53
2014 Topps Update 1989 Topps Minis Die-Cut #TM-MST Mel Stottlemyre	$0.55
2015 Topps 1972 Original Buyback #325 Mel Stottlemyre				$1.35
2017 Topps Rediscover Topps Buyback Bronze #44 Mel Stottlemyre	$1.33
2021 Topps Heritage 1972 50th Anniversary Buybacks #325 Mel Stottlemyre	$4.82

Copyright 1999-2022, Sportlots, LLC. All rights reserved.Privacy Policy
Use of Sportlots Web site constitutes acceptance our Agreement Terms.